The attacker poisons a DNS cache to take over authority for a given domain. The attacker then creates a phishing page and tries to steal user's usernames/passwords. There are two classes of experiments that need to be combined:
    a. an experiment where a DNS cache is poisoned, subclass of cache poisoning experiments
    b. an experiment where a phishing attack is conducted via a Web page to steal usernames/passwords

== Example 2: DNS cache poisoning for phishing ==

This example used two metadescriptions. Let's go through each of them. This example is written in [CurrentlyProposedLanguage]. 

=== Cache poisoning metadescription ===


 * '''Logical topology:''' 

    '''Objects:'''

      Attacker extends Node
  
      Name, fakeResource extends String

      Cache extends Object

      Cache := {String[] records}

    '''Cardinality:'''

      |Attacker|,,1,,

      |Name|,,1,,

      |fakeResource|,,1,,

      |Cache|,,1,,

    '''Relationships:'''

      not collocated(Cache, Attacker)


 * '''Timeline of events: '''

  '''Definitions:'''

    Attacker a, Cache c, Name n, fakeResource fr

    e1 := {type = REPLY, origin = a, destination = c, content = (n=fr)}

    s1 := {c.records += (n=fr)} 

  '''Timeline:'''

    e1 -> s1

 * '''Invariants:'''    Nothing in addition to the topology and timeline above.

=== DNS Cache poisoning metadescription ===

  This is a special case of cache poisoning where the target is DNS cache. 

 * '''Logical topology:''' 

  '''Objects:'''

    Attacker extends Node

    Auth extends Node

    Name extends DNSName

    RealIP extends IPAddress

    FakeIP extends IPAddress or fakeAuth extends DNSName

    victimCache extends Object
 
    victimCache := {DNSRecord[] records}

    authCache extends Object

    authCache := {DNSRecord[] records = {Name=RealIP, auth(domain(Name)) = Auth}

  '''Cardinality:'''

    |Attacker|,,1,,

    |Auth|,,1,,

    |Name|,,1,,

    |FakeIP|,,1,,

    |fakeAuth|,,1,,

    |RealIP|,,1,,

    |victimCache|,,1,,

    |authCache|,,1,,

  '''Relationships:'''

    not collocated(victimCache, Attacker)

    not collocated(victimCache, Auth)
 
    collocated(authCache, Auth)


 * '''Timeline of events: '''

  '''Definitions:'''

    Attacker att, Auth auth, Name n, FakeIP fIP, fakeAuth fauth, RealIP rIP, victimCache vc, authCache ac

      e1 := {type = DNSREQUEST, origin = att, destination = vc, content = IP(n)?}

      e2 := {type = DNSREQUEST, origin = vc, destination = auth, content = IP(n)?}

      e3 := {type = DNSREPLY, origin = auth, destination = vc, content = {n=rIP}}

      e4 := {type = DNSREPLY, origin = auth, destination = vc, content = {n=unknown}}

      e5 := {type = DNSREPLY, origin = att, destination = vc, content = {auth(domain(n)) = dnsname(fakeAuth)}}

      s1 := {vc.records += (auth(domain(n)) = fakeAuth)}

      e6 := {type = DNSREPLY, origin = att, destination = vc, content = {n=fIP}}

      s2 := {vc.records += (n=fIP)}

  '''Timeline:'''

      e1 -> e2 -> (e5 -> s1 -> e4 xor e6 -> s2 -> e3) 


 * '''Invariants:'''    Nothing in addition to the topology and timeline above.

=== Confidential access metadescription ===
 
   The phishing attempt is essentially same as presenting a valid page to the user that asks for confidential info - it's just that the location of that page is not as user expected. 

Dimensions:
 * '''Logical topology:''' 

  ''Objects:''

      User extends Human

      Server extends webServer

      Page extends webPage

      Public, Confidential extends String

  ''Cardinality:''

    |User|,,1,,

    |Server|,,1,,

    |Page|,,>=1,,

    |Public|,,1,,

    |Confidential|,,1,,

  ''Relationships:''

    collocated(Page, Server)

 * '''Timeline of events: '''

  ''Definitions:''

    User u, Server s, Public p, Confidential c, Page wp

      e1 := {type = WEBREQUEST, origin = u, destination = s, content = url(wp)}

      e2 := {type = WEBREQUEST, origin = s, destination = u, content = (public?, confidential?)}

      e3 := {type = WEBREPLY, origin = u, destination = s, content = (public=x, confidential=y)}

      e4 := {type = WEBREPLY, origin = s, destination = u, content = wp}

  ''Timeline:''

      e1 -> e2 -> e3 -> if (x == p and y == c) then e4
 

 * '''Invariants:'''    Nothing in addition to the topology and timeline above.

=== Experiment design ===

Now I'm a user who wants to design an experiment. I need to combine two metadescriptions (DNS cache poisoning and phishing) and somehow tie them down to generator choices. To combine I'll do something like this:
  
  DNSCachePoisoning dcp, confidentialAccess ca
  
    dcp.FakeIP := ip(ca.Server)
  
    dcp -> ca